A fought-over ADU is officially done. Two California neighbors’ war over it may not be.

30.07.2025    The Mercury News    4 views
A fought-over ADU is officially done. Two California neighbors’ war over it may not be.

The two-year battle over a controversial backyard apartment in Crown Point escalated to a new level this week with two visits by San Diego police accusations of trespassing and new threats of litigation The source of the argument is a zoning loophole that has pitted neighbor against neighbor in coastal communities by allowing backyard apartments also called accessory dwelling units or ADUs to be built directly along property lines RELATED California is so eager for homeowners to build ADUs it s helping them save on architect fees A worker squeezes between a fence and a wall to finish painting an ADU on Tuesday July in San Diego Ana Ramirez The San Diego Union-Tribune In Crown Point Heidi Martin and her family have been unable to paint the last wall of their new ADU because it s right on the property line and neighbor Marc Umemoto has repeatedly refused to let them use his yard to finish it Umemoto blames the city for allowing an ADU to be built so close to his property that it walls off his yard keeping sunlight and breezes out and changing the character of his home just a sparse blocks from Mission Bay And he blames Martin for taking advantage of that rule After a great number of months of failed negotiations between the neighbors the contractor for Martin took the extraordinary step Monday of trying to paint the final wall from Martin s property using a long pole with a roller attached When the painter lost his balance and stepped onto Umemoto s property around a m Umemoto called the police and accused the contractor of trespassing The officers who arrived refused to make an arrest or issue a citation both neighbors say When the painter again lost his balance just after noon Umemoto again called the police Different officers arrived and they too left without arresting or ticketing anyone I had a long discussion with the police and they won t do anything unless they witness it themselves Umemoto disclosed Tuesday And it s not a severe enough trespassing for them to be cited To Umemoto this program should be a warning to all San Diego residents that it s essentially useless to put up no trespassing signs or install cameras which he did shortly after the Martins began construction of the ADU It s kind of a waste of time he disclosed A worker squeezes between a fence and a wall to finish painting an ADU on Tuesday July in San Diego Ana Ramirez The San Diego Union-Tribune But to Martin this week is yet another regrettable chapter in an unfortunate dispute that she says has unfairly portrayed her as specific sort of neighborhood enemy Related Articles So several reasons to stay put What s behind California s frozen housing field California home sales below average with prices at record high Trump vs the Fed Should interest rates drop California s property insurance apocalypse A few progress no immediate relief South Bay apartment hub bought in deal that tops million She has repeatedly pointed out that her family is building only one ADU nothing like the large ADU developments that have generated so much dispute and that they are not investors buying up properties for ADUs The guys should be done painting by the upcoming day and I hope it s over after that Martin disclosed It s just been a mess She announced the police quite reasonably stated the painters to be safe and not focus so intently on avoiding Umemoto s property that they injure themselves We re not doing anything wrong we just want the wall painted she revealed Martin noted that she had to abandon a longtime plan to stucco the final wall because Umemoto wouldn t allow it Instead they are using elastomeric waterproof paint to cover the final wall s yellow gypsum-based sheathing board She reported her lawyers made multiple offers to Umemoto to get his permission to use his yard for just one day so they could finish the ADU A worker finishes painting an ADU on Tuesday July in San Diego Ana Ramirez The San Diego Union-Tribune Umemoto confirms such offers were made but announced they got bogged down by liability release forms other red tape and his frustration with the Martin s arguments It may have been a good method but their reasoning for it was unacceptable he reported Umemoto announced he considered going to court to block the painting but decided it was seemingly too late He s still considering suing for damages The City Council outlawed building backyard apartments on property lines in April but the new rule couldn t take effect in the city s coastal neighborhoods without a second approval from the California Coastal Commission That approval wasn t finalized until last September nearly two and a half years after the city s move In the interim dozens of backyard apartments were built directly on property lines in coastal neighborhoods

Similar News

Canada and Malta to recognize Palestinian state, joining France and possibly Britain
Canada and Malta to recognize Palestinian state, joining France and possibly Britain

Both countries said they would make the formal announcement at the UN General Assembly in New York i...

31.07.2025 0
Read More
Trump Said To Be Seriously Considering a Pardon for Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs, as Judge Ponders Whether To Release Producer From Squalid Jail
Trump Said To Be Seriously Considering a Pardon for Sean ‘Diddy’ Combs, as Judge Ponders Whether To Release Producer From Squalid Jail

Mr. Combs, who was acquitted of the most serious charges brought against him after an eight week tri...

31.07.2025 2
Read More
Brown University strikes agreement with White House to restore lost federal funding
Brown University strikes agreement with White House to restore lost federal funding

Brown University will pay $50 million to Rhode Island workforce development organizations in a deal ...

31.07.2025 2
Read More